Football Friday Night Scoreboard

Man Accused Of Killing Girlfriend’s Dogs Has Previous Arrest Records

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

Fayetteville man John Christopher Short was arrested Wednesday night on suspicion of aggravated animal cruelty. Short was released from the Washington County Detention Center on a $7500 bond Thursday afternoon.

According to an arrest warrant, a dog belonging to Short's girlfriend died under suspicious circumstances in March. Police said the dog named Esther had a fractured rear left leg that had to be amputated before its death. The girlfriend, Marye Scantlin, replaced Esther with a puppy named Hector.

In the report, Scantlin said she came home from work one day in April to find her new puppy dead. The report states that Short told Scantlin, "It is not breathing...I think it is dead."

A doctor's report shows Hector died from multiple skull fractures.

Court records show Short has been in trouble with authorities before. In February of 2014, Short pleaded guilty to assault and domestic battery in connection with hitting his girlfriend. In the last two years, two women have filed protection orders against him. In 2012, police said Short shot and killed a man in a struggle over a gun at Short's home. No charges were filed in that case.

Caroline Smith is Short's aunt, and said there is no way Short is capable of hurting an animal.

"We've always had dogs...Chris would not hurt a dog," Smith said.

Smith said Short was a sergeant in Afghanistan in 2005 when his Humvee was hit by an IED. She said Short's leg was amputated, and he suffered a traumatic brain injury as well as multiple surgeries on his elbow.

"They said 'animal cruelty' and I said 'what you've got to be crazy...he doesn't be cruel to any animals. He's got two in the house and I've got one!" Smith said.

Short's next court appearance will be September 17. For more information on the story, click here.


  • Dick Peters

    This imbecile is guilty! He should be put to death for his crimes. He has shown a pattern of behavior that dictates the use of capital punishment!

  • Steven

    Can’t believe this guy shot and killed someone and nothing happened. The guy he killed was probably trying to get the gun away from John to keep himself from getting shot. Then you have Jermaine Taylor with probably similar circumstances and he’s arrested. This just shows how differently people are treated here in the U.S.

  • Richard S. Drake

    Here is a question no one seems to want to touch upon – is he a different man since his military experience?

    You are a pretty tough guy, “Dan,” telling a woman whose only crime is that she loves her relation to “shut up.”

Comments are closed.