Elkins Woman Arrested, Released In Murder-For-Hire Of Ex-Husband

This is an archived article and the information in the article may be outdated. Please look at the time stamp on the story to see when it was last updated.

An Elkins woman is out of jail on bond after deputies say she solicited someone to kill her ex-husband and offered a guitar and a Winnebago camper as payment.

Teri Lea Baber was arrested Wednesday on suspicion of solicitation of murder. She was released Thursday from the Benton County Jail on $10,000 bond, according to the Benton County Sheriff’s Office.

Tabitha Cleveland, the woman Baber allegedly tried to hire to kill her ex-husband, came forward to authorities after the offer, said Deputy Keshia Guyll of the Benton County Sheriff’s Office.

Cleveland recorded a phone call with Baber on May 13, in which Baber offers Cleveland money, land, a guitar and a Winnebago camper to kill her ex-husband, according to a probable cause report from Benton County Circuit Court. Baber told Cleveland she owed her ex-husband $45,000 to keep her land and home, the report states.

Baber suggests Cleveland meet the ex-husband at Ozark Lanes in Fayetteville, since he takes part in a bowling league there. She said Cleveland could slip LSD into his coffee and flirt with him, the report states. Cleveland could then get him alone and shoot him with a gun, or convince him to shoot himself, the report states Baber suggested.

Baber wanted Cleveland to write a suicide note in the man’s handwriting leaving everything to Baber, according to the report.